Sacred Music Colloquium
Church Music Association of America
attended by Stephanie Swee
For the second year in a row, I was privileged to attend the
Sacred Music Colloquium of the Church Music Association of America (henceforth
referred to as CMAA). For the second year in a row, it was held in the
beautiful Cathedral of the Madeleine in Salt Lake City.
It felt very much like coming home, not only because of the
venue, but because there were some familiar faces among the more than 200 who
gathered: some of the staff of CMAA whom I had gotten to know previously, some
clergy, such as Father Johannes of the Gray Franciscans and Father Pasley, the
chaplain of CMAA, who is pastor of the only diocesan parish in the country
dedicated to the extraordinary form of the liturgy.
In addition, there were five other Oregon residents there,
besides the two of us who came from Central Oregon. Father Eric Andersen, until
recently pastor at Sacred Heart In Gervais and his choir director Jeannine,
Father Luan Tran, pastor of St. Birgitta’s parish in Portland and his choir
director, a young man whose name I never ascertained and a gentleman from Otter
Rock on the coast, whom I met once at the opening dinner and never saw the rest
of the week.
Initially, SLC was characteristically hot. After enduring a
Mass the first night in the choir school chapel (no air conditioning) with outside
temps of 109 degrees, we were grateful for highs in the mid-80s the rest of the
week and most classrooms and the cathedral were mercifully cooled. Once I was in the cathedral itself, however,
everything seemed very familiar and comfortable. The structure, with its
incredible frescos, stained glass and massive organ is perhaps as close as one
gets in the U.S. to the great cathedrals of Europe. The choir stalls provided a
lot of seating for some of the schola groups and the choir loft and screened area
behind the altar accommodated other singers. The acoustics are very good in
most areas and that made singing more satisfying than it is in more dampened
new churches, where carpet and ceiling tiles often absorb much of the sound.
As last year, there were six liturgies planned: two EF and
four OF Masses. Most of the priests – more than a dozen of them attending –
concelebrated the OF Masses and the choir school chapel was available for those
needing to say private Masses. I suspect most did that in the early morning, so
as to avoid being cooked and/or dehydrated.
The Masses were structured for the weekdays so as to begin
with English OF Masses, first with the New English Propers – amazingly simple
in the context – and then with Latin propers, more complex but very doable by
any choir willing to put in the time. Despite the fact that I looked forward to
the two Solemn High EF Masses on Thursday and Friday, I found the two preceding
Novus Ordo Masses very edifying. They were a great improvement over how most such
Masses are celebrated locally. The music, of course, was key, as chant in both
languages and sacred polyphony accompanied the action of the liturgy.
After a late start due to a failed alarm the first morning,
I decided to rejoin my previous schola director, Jeffrey Morse, currently
choirmaster at St. Stephen’s Church, a Fraternity of St. Peter parish in
Sacramento , CA. Even though the level of chant preparation was down from the
advanced schola, we had five or six men who were very good cantors and who did
all the intoning and psalm verses. In addition, since we had less ambitious
content to rehearse, Jeffery was able to give us instruction in semiology, the
applying of ancient text and markings to interpreting the chants. Although we
stayed with the general reforms of Solesmes for the chant, some nuances were
added here and there based on more recent scholarship.
Wednesday was a day for one of the highlights of the week.
Archbishop Alexander Sample, newly installed as archbishop of the Portland
archdiocese and metropolitan for the states of Oregon, Idaho and Montana,
visited for the day and gave a talk that brought tears to the eyes of many colloquium participants. He thanked the CMAA
for continuing to carry the torch for good sacred music and pledged to do all
in his power to further those efforts. One of the priests there said to me
afterwards that he had never expected in his lifetime to hear a member of the
hierarchy say those things. The gratification and gratitude on the part of
every participant was immense.
That evening Archbishop Sample celebrated an OF Mass ad
orientem and with some Latin chants. It occurred to me – and others, as it
turned out – that he is cut from the same cloth as was the Venerable Fulton
Sheen. Both have charismatic qualities and both are dignified in their bearing
and courageous in their attitude toward the faith. In Archbishop Sample’s case,
this includes especially the restoration of the sacred in liturgy and music,
which has lain in ruins for so long. It was a note of hope and optimism sorely
needed in the Church.
Thursday brought the first EF Mass, the traditional Solemn
Requiem for deceased members of CMAA. Monsignor Richard Schuler is always
remembered by name, for his incredible contribution to the cause of sacred music.
For nearly four decades he conducted Masses by Mozart, Haydn and other
composers and used Gregorian chant at many Masses at the Church of St. Agnes in
St. Paul, Minnesota. His legacy lives on in the Twin Cities Catholic Chorale
and CMAA will have a special workshop there in October.
On Friday, we celebrated the feast of the young Jesuit,
Aloysius Gonzaga, with another solemn high Mass, led by Father Pasley as
celebrant. On Saturday, the 2 p.m. Mass was an OF Mass in Latin in honor of Our
Lady. The group I was singing with did the beautiful Salve Sancta Parens
The colloquium wound up Sunday morning celebrating the
regular 11 a.m. parish Mass at the cathedral with the pastor, Mgsr. Mayo, as
celebrant. After Mass the entire group sang a new composition, Laudate
Dominum, selected from several pieces of sacred music submitted for
At the closing brunch, Jeffrey Tucker, editor of CMAA’s
publication Sacred Music, made a few remarks. A man not known for his brevity,
Tucker said that words had failed him in describing the experience of the
colloquium. He opined that the bonding felt among participants would continue
throughout the year and that the staff was happy to be in touch with any and all.
Father Pasley, though, said something that struck a
particular chord with me. He thanked all the participants for their rendering
of the sacred music and its contribution to the liturgies that week. He told us
that our efforts had made the clergy better priests and that at times, he felt
chills on hearing the beautiful sounds that befit the Sacrifice of the Mass done properly.
Next year the colloquium will be held in Indianapolis,
Indiana, much farther east. I hope to be there, but it is a long way out to
plan. What I did get from some of the staff is that they are considering
Portland as a venue in the next few years. Between the friendship of Archbishop
Sample and the more temperate climate, that would be very happy event. Meanwhile, there are signs of progress in
Oregon and perhaps some of the wonderful liturgy that happened in Salt Lake
City this summer will be echoed around our state over the next months of
If anyone wants more information about CMAA or its
activities, including the last colloquium, please e-mail me at: email@example.com.